Blog Archive

Thursday, July 15, 2010

Trip Update #2

July 8

Bonjour tout le monde! I have much to update you on since the last time I wrote, which I believe was my first day here. It's now been four full days that I've been in Paris, though it seems like an eternity since I left. Paris is one of the cities that really immerses you... and with all the metro trips, moped rides, walking "tours" (aka getting really lost), these days can seem really long. Well, I'll get to the update now.

I've had two interviews: one with a professor of European History, Dr. Terence Murphy, who runs the Foundation of the US, a college connected to the Cité Universitaire international school in Paris, HERE.


We had a pretty interesting discussion, although he unfortunately seemed a little unknowledgeable about the topic. He did give me an interesting perspective on elites in the government, who by nature of the education system, essentially determine everything. Basically, if you don't succeed on this mondo bid test at the end of your high school career, you won't be placed in the top schools in France, and won't therefore be able to rise very far. The top 5,000 jobs in France are occupied almost exclusively by the men and women who graduate from those schools... Its a very corporatist structure, similar to Mexico's. Dr. Murphy did a good job connecting this with the plight of immigrants in France... the elites who run government and make education policy haven't really made substantive changes since the reign of Napoléon. So its the immigrants, who are raised in bad homes, in bad neighborhoods, and who are discriminated against, who get the bad grades and don't do well on the end-of-year tests, who lose out.. they, then deprived of both status (not going to the good schools) and money (because they can't get even subpar jobs, thanks to widespread discrimination, not to mention poor school records), they turn to acts of anger and rebellion: crime, riots, a "culture gangsteur"... we see the same patterns in the US, of course... France is actually turning to affirmative action practices to help the situation. You wouldn't think they would, given their reputation for egalitarianism, but I think France is realizing they need to stop the cycles of poverty somehow.

My second interview was with Dr: Christine Marie-Navarro, a prof of French Studies at the American University of Paris. Her father, as it turns out, was Moroccan, and actually fought in the Algerian War in the late 1950s and early 60s. She gave an interesting perspective too... she reminded me of the complexity of identity... her father considered himself absolutely 100% French, but she herself identifies herself more regionally as a Mediterranean. She encouraged to be careful how I focus my thesis... do I mean to study North Africans in France? Because there are Algerians, Moroccans, Tunisians, all of whom have different cultures, and the identities in fact break down even further... Berber v. Kabylian for example. I really enjoyed this interview. All in French too!

Beyond interviewing, I've been doing a lot of journaling, based not just on my interviews, but on journal articles, and on observations. This is thanks to Dr. Mazzei's suggestion that I record everything I think about or see... it'll come in handy when it comes to actually writing the thesis. I've really enjoyed sitting down at the end of the day, or after a big interview, and writing all my thoughts, perhaps accompanied by a steaming cup of expresso or two.



It helps me to direct my research, so I'm not just stumbling around trying to find something to write about. For example, I was thinking hard about the socioeconomic troubles of the immigrants here... and I thought, it always seem to get worse during economic crises. I remember reading that in the 1970s, after the big gas crisis (called the choc petrolier en français), France began to slide economically. Politicians began to blame immigrants for suffocating the social security system (healthcare, unemployment), and also for taking jobs that should have gone to hardworking French. Boy, this sounds all too familiar these days... I think the French turn to the right in times of crisis. They start talking about cutting government programs, and immigration is always brought up... the burqa definitely wouldn't be an issue now if the economic crisis weren't so in everyone's faces. Which leads me to my third update...

I sent some emails to some French députés this morning (think Congressman), because I had heard to watch a session of Parliament in person, you needed the endorsement of one of them. I didn't think I woudl hear back, honestly, because I imagined they were big and bad and popular and had no time to answer emails (like US politicians). But lo and behold, an hour later, I got an email back from Député François Asensi's office that said he would be happy to grant my request, and that I was to meet at the Parliament building, l'Assemblée Nationale, at 2:30. At this point I was at a cyber café in the middle of town, so I had to scramble around four different metro lines to get back to the apartment, change out of my sandals tee shirt and gym shorts.. I made it there on the dot. I entered the Parliament Hall with all the other visitors... it was an amazingly ornate hall, with lots of paintings of the French Révolution and of Greek gods and goddesses dotting the ceiling. The actual debate took place with a little over 20 députés in attendance... but what it lacked in warm bodies, it more than made up for in substance and passion of "débat." Though the conversation was on simply banning face coverings in public (not directed at burqas or niqabs), it turned into a debate into the fundamentals of the French state... what France stands for, what it "is" qnd what it represents to the world and to the citizens. The politicians were passionate and extremely articulate... I felt like I was at the Constitutional Convention. It was more a debate on political philosophy than anything else. What I got from it was a sense of the importance of the current time period in France... that France is at a crossroads economically, culturally, politically... there are scandals in government, new laws being debated about the direction the quasi Socialist government should take (whether to raise taxes or cut spending or both)... this is just one part of a really complex and comprehensive change taking place, not just in France but all over Europe. It was a fabulous experience, I have so much more to say, but you'll just have to read about it in my thesis!

Tomorrow, I plan on going to La Grande Mosquée de Paris (the large mosque of Paris) to interview an imam in the afternoon... and will also stop over at the Arab World Institute and Library (just built!) to do some study. My goal is to try and do things here that I couldnt do through my laptop sitting my butt in Kent. With the internet, that's not a lot... but just being here, doing some observing, talking one-on-one with people, has enormous value. I hope to come home with more information in my head than before, a better researcher, a better French speaker, but most importantly, a wiser person on how people form their identities and how complex the human psyche is.



Reponse to a professor's email

July 9

Written in response to an email I received from a very nice professor :) on the banning of the "voile intégrale" (meaning burka or niqab) in public

Article Link: http://pewresearch.org/pubs/1658/widespread-support-for-banning-full-islamic-veil-western-europe-not-in-america?src=prc-latest&proj=forum

My response:
I suspected this, actually, but hadn't gone looking for a poll to confirm. You know Dr. Robyn, the interesting thing is, I don't think people actually care too much about this issue. For one, it's only going to affect the decisions of 2000 woman. So what does Michel care, or Sylvianne, or that fisherman in Breton... it's too bad perhaps for those women, but that is the downside to being in the minority, sometimes you get stepped on. Even Muslims, I think, don't have much to say on the subject. I talked to a secretary of the mosque yesterday who said she didn't really mind one way or the other... I think there's a split between Muslims... most WANT to assimilate, stop being noticed, go on as French citizens. There is a future in that, for you, and for your kids. I've learned the one thing the French hate more than anything is a "situation précaire"... or a precarious economic situation.

Not to mention most of these immigrants immigrated here ten years ago or more, meaning they grew up French. They don't know much about their great-grandparent's lives, or the struggle against the French, and even if they do, they have no connection to it outside of these stories have very little resonance in their lives today.

I also think there's a perception in the greater Muslim population that those radical Muslims who are fighting against the "interdiction de la voile intégral" are troublemakers, ruining it for the rest of the Muslims (like 10% of the country!).

I thought this would be a huge issue when I came... but I think the larger question as you know is the survival of the nation, the confirmation of the political philosophy that has kept France's democracy intact for two centuries (well, really, 130... well, then there was that whole WW2 thing... ok, let's be honest, the French have not been great at democracy). Like I said in my email, the parliament session was an inspiring and rousing debate on the fundamentals of the nation... I heard "liberté, égalité, fraternité, laicité, la patrimoine, la sécurité" I don't know sixty times... if I was playing french democracy buzz word bingo, I'd had five across in the first ten minutes. This I think is the worst part about the ban, which looks like it will go through. I don't think there's anything anti-laique about women wearing the burqa... the veil will still be allowed, so what we're talking about is a one foot by one foot piece of fabric across the face. I can't see how this is anti-équalité... but it's definitely anti-fraternité and liberté... so I guess even though the ban will have little effect on the population, it is framing the constitutional in a certain way that for me is indefensible. Maybe you can enlighten me on their justification... I mean, I get that is representative of women's repression and abuse at home, and I get that it may pose a security threat (no, wait, I don't... but I at least acknowledge the legitimacy of that argument in a world of globalized terror)... but I don't get how it violates anything about the founding principles of government. This is actually what many in the Left, esp the more radical ones, were referring to. That this issue gets brought up during troubling economic times... it's a smokescreen for more assimilationist policies, creating a homogenous country without the "droit de difference"... the left also indicated, and this is the divide among scholars of the issue too, that these burqaed women have to right to recognition from the governmentfor their free choice of religion. I agree with that argument, though I know I am American and bias more towards liberty than equality. Burke and I would have a hard time hangin' out.

Sorry I talked your ear off on the subject, but I was just thinking about it (obviously, this is what I am here for...).

Chris

Facebook post #3

Christopher Hook So, I was reading the top stories on Google's French homepage... scandals in government and the recovery of a missing child are the top stories (meaning most read). I then turn to the top US headlines: Joey Chestnut wins Hot Dog eating contest. That's about as brutal an example of the differences between US and French culture as can be.

Trip Hook
Yes, because Lord knows every American loves and cares about competitive hot dog eating. I think it's got more to do with the demographics of Google users in the respective countries.


Christopher Hook
Ok, but I guarantee you couldnt find a sizeable segment of the French population who would care so friggin much about competitive cheese eating. Americans across the country care about the contest: thats why it is shown on national television. Even if it is a cult phenomenon, it says something about us as a nation


Trip Hook
Do any Americans you know REALLY care about competitive hot dog eating? What it says about us as a nation is that, from time to time, we enjoy watching people do silly things. Incidentally, the headline in my morning paper was "Inflatable Cow Fishing Contest Underway in Sète".


Christopher Hook ok, that is a regional contest. its not something paris or even marseilles cares about. and yeah, i think we care about it, like we care about any cult phenomenon like reality TV. and its become a 4th of july tradition... traditions say a lot about us

Christopher Hook
and it wouldnt be so bad, except that we make these kinds of things part of our daily lives... not to mention that competitive eating is so representative of a nation of excess, of bad health, of consumption; admittedly france has some of these qualities (watch the movie la grande bouffe).

Trip Hook
Really? Hot dog eating contests are a part of our daily lives? I'm quite sure that they write articles like this because people read it and laugh at the very notion of a hot dog eating contest, if not that the top dog in the field (no pun intended) is a petite Japanese guy. It's not even an American newspaper that reported this!

Trip Hook
Just do me a favor and don't be one of those Americans that comes to Europe and starts validating and reinforcing negative and silly stereotypes. Our culture has its faults like any other, but I don't think gross gluttony like this represents me or the US that I know in any respect except that we like to laugh at people embarrassing themselves (turn on TF1 for 5 minutes and tell me the French don't feel the same way).

Christopher Hook
I'm not. In fact I defended America today from a French jeune who attacked us (in a less offensive way, i just cant think of another word at this late hour) for driving big cars... and i said that in fact thats changing, were driving smaller cars, the government is encouraging better emission standards on cars.. believe me, i'm not at all. And I suspect that the Nathan's Hot Dog contest is more than just a spectacle to laugh at.

Christopher Hook
joey chestnut was on letterman the other day... we love him, and that an American has finally taken the reins as hot dog champion of the world from kobayashi

Trip Hook
I don't know what gets people talking at water coolers in Ohio, but to suggest that Americans as a people "care" about the outcome of this event or take it seriously does not reflect my experience as an American. I cannot imagine a conversation taking place regarding this event that does not involve laughter, disbelief, or one where people actually know the competitors' names ahead of time. I don't find the 15 minutes of attention this events gets per year to be a particularly "brutal" revelation of our cultural inferiority.

Trip Hook
Also, it's convenient for Europeans to suggest that they drive smaller cars out of altruism and reverence for the environment, but I suspect is has as much to do with the high price of fuel and the incredibly narrow roads. I drove a compact to Spain last weekend and still can't believe the thing fit down some of the streets I had to take.

Devon Holliday
Hahaha. Did you watch the Colbert report "The Word" segment - "Who War It Best?" Basically highlighting the fact that America is at war and usually only those directly affected by it are those who are aware of that fact. When reading your status it was the first thing that came to my mind.


The Colbert ReportMon - Thurs 11:30pm / 10:30c
The Word - Who War It Best?
www.colbertnation.com
Colbert Report Full Episodes2010 ElectionFox News

Oh, BTW- The top two searches via Google trends as of 45 minutes ago were regarding Kobayashi.
I ♥ citizens of America!!

Michael Fhaner
Look Chris the economy is bad enough, lets not include the members of Major League Eating in the unemployment numbers. They have the right to work. Isn't that really what we are talking about a persons right to work.. :) As for the French, I am sure there is something we Americans would find silly that the French hold as a sacred tradition. Let them eat grapes.

Christopher Hook
Mr. Fhaner- Yeah, I don't protest anything about what they're doing... anything to make a buck. I'll down a bunch of lemonade-softened hot dogs on live TV if it earns me sponsorships and some cashola. Bring on Joey "Jaws" Chestnut, he apparently hasn't seen me down a dog before. It was probably a good thing I was in France for the 4th, or I woulda really cleared out some barbeques... Heh heh. PS- I hope the hot dog eating contest isn't really a "sacred tradition"-- I might barf from the thought of it. Is this what we fought the War against England for? To try and break 60 hot dogs in a minute? As long as we're not being taxed for them, I suppose...

Tripper- yeah, I don't think Europeans actually criticize us so much for all of our excesses... I do, but their criticism is mostly framed in ubiquitous arguments they learn from their parents and the media, just like we have our own stereotypes of them. I think most Europeans actually love and perhaps envy our culture... if only they knew we had public golf courses and public tennis courts (for free), we might see em over here in droves... not to mention the 65 cent big gulps and 2 dollar pitchers. Being excessive is fun and makes for a good time. But my argument dear cousin is that this provides a snapshot of a cultural tradition that framed in the traditional mindsets of Europeans, comes across as representative of the kind of America that shoots off fifty pounds of fireworks in our backyards just to watch shit blow up, votes in cowboy presidents because we'd "enjoy having a beer with him," and has an obesity problem that is one of the worst in the world. I think there is something inherent about a hot dog eating contest that distinguishes it from Europe. I can say that with some experience too. I cringe at what my German European Politics professor would say about such a spectacle...

Karlton 'Karty' Shoemaker
Joey Chestnut is a real American hero.


Debra-Lynn Hook
Ugh

Steven Zoller
lol. But I somehow feel like that is a plus for America - we're always looking on the bright side!


Trip Hook
Good points - I agree that it reinforces a stereotype, I just don't really agree that it's fair. To me, suggesting that this is indicative of American gluttony is like suggesting that the running of the bulls is indicative of a Spanish recklessness - silly traditions are the spice of life. Anyway, clearly I'm just battle hardened after 7 months of having this argument. The American obesity epidemic is far more complicated than a simple question of excess, but that notion is so deeply rooted in the global narrative on US culture that it's hard to crack.

Abby Greer
I'm just curious to know who Trip Hook is....GREAT discussion! I love your points!!!

Tuesday, July 13, 2010

Facebook Post #2

Christopher Hook : “a long and happy picnic with nothing to do but sit in comfort and fire the Golden Rule into those people down there and imagine letters to write home to the admiring families, and pile glory upon glory" -Mark Twain on the massacre of the Phillippines by US soliders

El' VaMeter
so i assume the golden rule has become death?



Christopher Hook
no, i think he was referring to solidiers attitude towards the philippinians, which was that they are savages, and we, we are the good christians doing whats right for our country and our little boys at home, etc. So we are firing the golden rule (aka our supremacy, albeit ignorant) into savages for our own glory)... very pessimistic.. and we actually lost this war though...

El' VaMeter
‎:) cool! i aught to check that piece out.. sooo like, do i like your status or your explanation?? XD

Brad Baranowski
Any particular reason why this is your status today?

    
Devon Holliday
What is so pessimistic, Mr. Optimist? Mark Twain's poignant quote or how wars are fought....?


Brad Baranowski
Wait a minute, I just read the NYT article hahaha. Well played sir

Christopher Hook
Larkin-- both!

Good question Brad... researching for my thesis in Paris has essentially been a study of the ego... and especially of the Western ego, with its MOs of supremacy, civilizing missions, etc. Not that I needed much prodding (to be more cynical on this topic), but I suppose I'm just uncovering more ways that white privilege and Western ... Afficher davantagesupremacy have manifested themselves throughout history. And killing massive amounts of people is one of the most evil. I hate the idea of civlizing mission, I really do. I guess this answers your question too Devon. Not to mention this apartment is BOILING, makes a man grouchy :)

Brad Baranowski
But if we don't help the barbarians become civilized how will they ever ascend out of backwardness and unGodliness?

El' VaMeter
dude you should definitely hit the town with a notebook and get out tof the heat-- elohel

Christopher Hook
Thank you Stanislaw Jr.

Brad Baranowski
Haha pas de probleme

Devon Holliday
Have you had a chat with Mr. Zoller about this topic? I think he would make you feel more optimistic about the benefits of western civilization. Beyond that, nearly all civilizations are drenched in blood, so don't get too upset about the atrocities brought on by Western civilizations :)

Question though, Weren't the French the most guilty out of... Afficher davantage all the early European colonizers for their "civilizing missions"?

Hope a strong breeze picks up so you can try to cool down a wee bit! In the mean time, I'll relish my AC.

Debra-Lynn Hook
so many quotes, so little time.

Trip Hook
I'd say this trait is less western than human. Westerners can just afford the biggest guns.

Christopher Hook
Brad- I want to get the autobiography!!!

Larkin-- I did. It was better.

Trip- that's definitely true, Marx nailed that one on the head too. But I think there's something about the Western ideology that makes leaders want to colonize the world, make it a better place. Yeah, you can argue empires in the east did this too, but I think there's a reason they were eventually defeated... capitalism!... Afficher davantage

Devon-- Haha no I haven't, Steven usually doesn't need any encouragement to jump in on our debates. But he hasn't yet.. strange. Maybe he's having dinner with his family, or hiking (kidding steven!). Yeah, the French did this with Algéria, explicitly described as a mission civilisatrice. There's a reason why this ubiquitous term is in French... Belgium did it in the Congo, England in India... there was a conference in Berlin in like 1887 where the European leaders basically laid out a map and choose what African countries they wanted. France was already ahead of them getting Algéria in 1830, but this is when a lot of the colonization of Africa happened. And I can't help but be upset, no matter the civilization, it just happens that I am a Westerner and have inherent feeling of guilt I just can't get over, especially spending my days in all black and North African neighborhoods...

Christopher Hook
Devon I realized I spelled ubiquitous wrong. I still cant spell it as you can see. I guess I am a dumb american... its interesting, sometimes we think of westerners as cold calculating intelligent beyond belief enough to build systems of repression for centuries and to beat nature and natural law.... but then we have a stereotype of a dumb american... Afficher davantage... i think those are two different levels of analysis though, the former being a historical materialist one, the latter being a rather lazy cultural stereotype with no real truth in it

Trip Hook
Well, colonialism packaged with a rationale and honest-to-God altruism are two different things. I realize that the West still does exploitative things that might qualify as neo-colonialism, but I can't think of too many examples in living history of us going into a foreign country and ostensibly trying to "tame the savages" like the good ol' days... Afficher davantage. If anything, the opposite is happening - the countries we ravaged in the old days want back in. It seems to me that the immigration troubles they're having in France now are a consequence of "reaping what we sow", even if it is several generations after the fact.

Devon Holliday
Haha - Don't worry, I figured we had a cease-fire on calling out each other's grammar/spelling mistakes. Besides - I think that is how you spell "Ubiquitous"....at least that is what the online dictionary is telling me!!

You really are such an optimist. I personally believe stereotypes are stereotypes for a reason (For instance, women are ... Afficher davantageterrible drivers and I will readily admit that I am a terrible driver) - and I *especially* believe that Americans have grown fat (have you see obesity rates????) and lazy (Have you seen heart attack rates???) and, most importantly, self-interested (see: Financial Crisis/infatuation with suing) True patriotism, that type that JFK called for, is a rarity nowadays (Hellooooo dismal voting rates/aspirations to serve one's country.) But you go on thinking the best of our fellow citizens. Somebody needs too. :)

Facebook Post #1

Christopher Hook
French National Assembly votes on burqa ban tomorrow... and no one in France, not even the Muslims, care. This is a very media- and US-driven controversy.

Trip Hook
I think it's not just the US, I've been reading about it in a lot of the international press. It's a landmark issue in a lot of ways, raises a lot of interesting ethical/legal questions being faced in a lot of countries, so I think a lot of people are interested in how things play out even if not that many people will really be affected.

Why do you think people are so disinterested here?

Christopher Hook
Well for one, people generally agree with the ban... they see it as in-line with French values, and don't see it as enough of a stain on liberty to really get riled up about it. The French are very rational... I think I heard Sarkozy use that word like six times during his interview on TV last night. And with only 2000 people using the "voile intégrale;" its not such a big deal with the other things going on, including unemployment, government scandals, reform of retirement, economic crisis, you know. The veil isnt really getting a lot of coverage these days.. very little in the major papers is being reported about the bill and the debate on it.... so obviously in the way that the media tells people what to care about...

It is a landmark issue for democracy, but I think for politicians here, its a way for them to have a discussion of the fundamentals of the state... when youre arguing for raising the retirement age, youre making no friends from the citizenry... but when you're arguing to preserve the core values of the state, talking about the Révolution and égalité, liberté, fraternité... you're definitely getting points. Not to mention who in the socialist or any other party wants to vote against a bill that is framed like the very survival of the french nation is at stake... thats why the socialists are refusing to vote at all I think...

Trip Hook
Yep, I've noticed that as well (the veil not getting much coverage). I must say I am impressed with the restraint people are showing - I feel like a symbolic law like this would cause a lot of bitter debate in the US. I was surprised that you identified it as a "US-driven controversy" since it is such an interesting issue that, as you put it, is essentially a proxy vote for the "very survival of the French nation".

Christopher Hook
Yeah, that may have been bad-wording on my part... I think what I meant was that a lot of attention has been given to it in US media... the NYT for example ran an article yesterday on the philosophy behind the ban... and they love to dote on the controversy surrounding it... one article I read said that an 'outcry' has gone up among the population... that may have been true when it was initially proposed, but now 83% of people support the ban... whoopdedoo. I think we in America love to jump on the bandwagon when liberty is being taken away, we love to think of ourselves as the saviors of the world's stricken. But the French have more important things to worry about right now I think...

Trip Hook
Yeah, 'outcry' sounds a little sensationalized. Realistically we all have bigger things to worry about. I feel like things like this tend to be weightier in the US because we're so fiercely wedded to precedent and symbolism, something about our country that I both admire (steadfast commitment to freedom of religious expression) and loathe (steadfast commitment to bringing handguns to work). It seems to me like the French pursue whatever policy makes sense without so much intensive focus on the 'big picture'.

Christopher Hook
Yeah, I agree with that whole post. It's a pragmatism... and what I like the most is that both sides try to use rational arguments to disprove the other, something I'm sure they're very proud of as decendants of Descartes and whatnot. I guess I would call it a respect for the other's opinions but most imporantly a regard for the country's future... sometimes worrying so much about your historical legacy can be a very good thing. I think back in disgust to last summer and the anti-healthcare rallies, with politicians saying anything they could just to attract the attention and the love of the Tea Partiers... there was no pragmatism there, no sense of country first...

Trip Hook
Yep, the health care debate was an example of the dark side of our 'big picture' thinking. For my part though, I would be fiercely opposed to a law like this in the US for largely the same reasons: the Tea Partiers see health care reform (fallaciously IMO) as a dangerous precedent for government control, whereas I would see a burqua ban as a dangerous precedent for limiting freedom of religious expression. I just wouldn't resort to their tactics...

Christopher Hook
Yeah, agreed. I was really frustrated last summer because I felt like, and fairly I think, everyone involved in healthcare was lying about it. It has really made me disillusioned about listening to politicians speak. Maybe that's why it's been such a breath of fresh air to follow French politics and not American for the last week and a half... politicians here are unafraid to say what they think (without worry that Keith Olbermann or Beck is gonna pounce on every word) and have enough respect for themselves and for the system that they are encouraged to be rather frank and unconcealed. Tea Partiers would argue that they have respect for the system... I see it as misguided.

Trip Update #1

July 4

I walked around Père-Lachaise Cemetery today. I felt so tacky, so unworldly, unrefined, stalking around the multi-acre cemetery in search of tombs to takes pictures of and prove that I’d been there. As if a photo of Honoré de Balzac’s final resting place is really going to improve me as a person, or make my trip any cooler to you, dear reader, or even to me. If someone thinks that I am cooler because I saw Oscar Wilde’s grave, it’s only because that person thinks I know something about him. And really, I don’t. Fail. But in fact none of the tombs really did anything for me. For that reason, I really respect the French culture. The French could have decked out each “noted” headstone with all kinds of arrows and biographies in multiple languages… but, they didn’t. Bizet’s, Piaf’s, even Molière’s were largely hidden—and it was only the large crowds around them that I even noticed their existences. That shows a real respect for privacy. If these were in America, I think we would really point it out. And headstones should never be whores, at least without the dead’s permission.

Père-Lachaise

Honore de Balzac, the man with the most unfortunate French-to-English translation name in history

George Bizet, operatic composer of "Carmen"



Fan at Jim Morrison's tomb



Paris in summer is beautiful, in its liveliness and warmth and classicness that just hit you at every corner. It can be overwhelming, actually. Paris is one of those cities that make you feel like you are somewhere.


Art and beauty are just sewn into the very fabric of this city. You get the feeling that everyone here is glad they are here, and nowhere else. It is not a city to “settle” for, but to embrace eternally. I like how, contrary to normal activity in America, the French need nothing more than to sit at a petit café with a cup of coffee and a cigarette, and chat with friends if they are there, although this isn’t a requirement. I imagine its been this way for a century or more… No wonder Picasso, Hemingway, Sartre and numerous painters, poets, writers, and poets spent much of their life here… creativity is everywhere and difficult not to find! The people here are happy; perhaps not outwardly- but ask them a question and they light up. Just make sure you ask it in French :)



I just read “France and its Muslims,” a Foreign Affairs article on Muslim life in the “Hexagon.” One of the interesting things the author noted was that there are two battles being fought between the Muslim community and contemporary France.



One of the struggles of the Muslim community is to advance out of its current socioeconomic situation. High poverty, high cost of living, crap homes, etc. These battles are being fought on the streets, between les flics et les ados, for example. Many times this struggle is being framed as a contentious struggle between Islam and its neocolonial oppressors the French government/way of life, most notably when Sarkozy called the (religious leaders) imams to quell violence after the 2005 riots in the banlieues. But these frames are out of touch with reality. In fact, religion has little to do with it. Religiosity is not terribly high among French Muslims. Like Karl Marx queried, the socioeconomic factors are bigger causes for urban unrest than any other, including religious motivations. This was demonstrated excellently by Matthew Kassowitz’s film “La Haine.”

Delivery man w/ truck at Chateau-Rouge, a predominantly immigrant neighborhood north of Paris

Women selling wares on the street at Chateau-Rouge

The second battle, similar but distinct, is the veil and its assorted brothers and sisters. Attacking the veil is one of the biggest mistakes the French government is making. This makes the situation a Muslim question, framing the battle once again as a East v. West, France v. the rest of the world scenario, when in fact, as previously demonstrated, the problem lies in the socioeconomic. What aspects of a Muslim person are really upsetting to a French person? I suppose that depends on the person, so let’s instead talk about what aspects upset social order and the preservation of the French way of life? To the first, nothing. To the second, again, this depends on the perception. So the question goes to: whose perception are we operating under? This is a complex question and be be answered by analyzing how power and policy are handed down in the country. As Giry (author of the FA article) wrote and I agree, power and policy are being handed down by a small percentage of elites.

French députés coming out for lunch break
National Assembly, the highest house of the French legislature

A pretty good rest of the day. The Arab Institute was enormous- didn’t think the “vie arabe” would get such coverage, but there you go. Probably paid for by the Saudis. I would bet the construction of the building, which is right in the center of the city, was a play at being more inclusive, multicultural. I wonder if it got any controversy… I should ask.

Institut du Monde Arabe

Happy Indépendence Day @USofA !

One

I have started this blog to keep my thoughts organized while I travel and study and research in Paris this summer, July 2 to the 20th. Though I am only starting this on the 13, I don’t really think it matters... I have written extensively in my “ink” blog that has been my constant companion for the past week and a half. It appears to be showing some age, though who wouldn’t after being dragged around one of the top ten biggest cities in the world, trapped in a green saddlebag and being assaulted by whatever implement happens to be in there that day... today it was a piece of fruitcake that I mistakenly thought would be chocolate, and upon discovering it was not, hastily stowed in my bag in the hopes that my hunger pangs would eventually overtake my taste buds’ very specific preferences. They did not... and in revenge for not being wanted, the fruitcake laid waste to my notebook the best it could... which meant leaving small little cake-colored stains on the edges of my journal pages. I got the final word. It’s now sitting at the bottom of a poubelle waiting for its demise. I have also written a lot on facebook, and in emails to people... I will include these as well.

I was going to wait until I got back to Kent to read my writings, but as I have three hours+ until my cousin arrives from Montpellier, and I am feeling particularly rigorous right now, I’ll dive into it right now. No time like the present, and all that, right? I just hope this attitude stays with me when the semester begins, which for me is right when I get home… I’m starting a three-week course on Earth History.

So, here goes. I will add more notes after having read and dissected what I wrote earlier. I am feeling like I have a very good mastery of the basics so far… like, I could probably teach a course to a class of undergraduates, even a motivated class.

But I worry about a lot of things relating to my research thus far… and before I write I want to lay them out.

1) I did not focus enough on the Muslim identity question
Upon reflection, I think this is a fair critique. But I still have hopefully many interviews to go on Thursday and Friday… I know that if I have not done enough by Friday at prayer time, my instincts will kick in and I will find the courage to approach immigrants in the North African areas and ask them about their lives in France. I think I have quite a lot on French national identity… and perhaps this is where I am more interested in going with the thesis. I hope the Honor’s College, who accepted my proposal and gave me a cool thou to go on this trip and research, will understand if the final work deviates a bit from the original idea. I imagine this happens a lot, and dare I say, every time, you have an idea, and then you really dig deep into it. In the final analysis, I will focus my research wherever I think it is the most pertinent.

2) I didn’t do enough “substantive” research while in France
Perhaps. But at the end of the trip, through fourteen days, I will have (I apologize for the double colon): gone to the Arab World Institute Library, done up to seven interviews, observed the French Parliament in debate, talked to Jean and his girlfriend extensively on the subject, lived in a banlieue and observed the social interactions, gone to the Rue Myrha area twice for observation and once for interview emailed and or called and or visited about twenty professors, the Arab World Institute, SOS Racisme, the Office for Intégration et La Ville Politique, read every article in my possession, taken notes on possible sources to use for the final paper, and followed current events like it was my job (well, kind of…). I don’t feel like I took too much time for just chilling. I have been in a constant state of drowsiness, heat exhaustion, dehydration, and stress over keeping my shit in order (AKA not losing anything…)… I think I’ve done a lot. Maybe not all I should have… but I do feel like I have an incredible grasp over the situation here, especially the controversy surrounding the veil, and the difference between that question, and then immigrant struggles for jobs, better schooling, less discrimination, etc. This needs to be further developed, I know, but I have a great outline by which to go when I start the actual writing when the semester begins. The carol awaits…

Didn’t have enough to do while in France
I agree with this. What I could have done better is to make more contacts before I went, been more proactive up to now about approaching people, called instead of emailed, spent my weekend a little better (more work, less free time). The being proactive thing has been difficult, for sure… my flopping language skills have been really stressing me out and definitely not augmenting my confidence to approach random strangers and ask them intimate details on their lives. The other things, many of the professors, including Rita Kastoryano and Christian Joppke, are on vacation. So was the man from the Bureau d’intégration, and probably a lot of other contacts who are now lost to me. That was going to happen no matter if I called them three months before I left or three days… I will need to come up with a dossier of names and contact information for some serious email interviewing and possibly Skyping.

Now that I’ve dissected those, I want to acknowledge in fairness some things I had no control over, or very little at least, which prevented me from having 100% success. These include: many contacts being on vacation, the apartment being an hour from the city center, my all-of-a-sudden weak French skills, the heat and other physical detriments, money, time, unfamiliarity with phones, subway and bus lines, etc. It is not important to me about laying blame… but I want to absolve myself psychologically. I have a fear of failure, for sure, and knowing that my shortcomings on this trip weren’t all mine to stagger under, helps some.

So anyway, finally, let’s get to the transcription and subsequent comments-upon reflection that arise from them, and you’ll forgive me if I make some edits to a few poorly written sentences…